Skip to content
Indonesian Scientific Journal

Plagiarism Policy

Plagiarism Policy

Jurnal Janitra Informatika dan Sistem Informasi

Jurnal Janitra Informatika dan Sistem Informasi (Janitra) is committed to upholding originality, academic integrity, transparency, and ethical standards in scholarly publishing. The journal does not tolerate plagiarism, inappropriate duplication, or the misrepresentation of intellectual contributions in submitted manuscripts or published articles.

This policy elaborates on the journal's Publication Ethics and Malpractice Statement and is informed by the principles of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) . It describes the forms of plagiarism, responsibilities of authors, procedures for similarity assessment, and editorial responses to suspected or substantiated violations.

Plagiarism Policy at a Glance

Originality: Required for all manuscripts
Plagiarism: Prohibited
Similarity Screening: Turnitin or iThenticate
Assessment: Similarity reports and editorial judgment
Author Clarification: Opportunity to respond to concerns
Editorial Actions: Clarification, revision, or rejection
Post-Publication Actions: Correction or retraction when warranted

1. Definition and Scope of Plagiarism

Plagiarism occurs when an individual presents the words, ideas, research findings, data, methods, or other intellectual contributions of another person or source as their own without appropriate acknowledgment. Plagiarism may occur intentionally or through inadequate citation and attribution practices.

Potential forms of plagiarism and inappropriate publication overlap include:

  • Direct Plagiarism: Reproducing text from another source without appropriate quotation or acknowledgment.
  • Paraphrasing Plagiarism: Rewriting another author's ideas, arguments, or findings without proper attribution.
  • Mosaic Plagiarism: Combining words, phrases, or passages from multiple sources while presenting them as original writing.
  • Data and Figure Plagiarism: Using another researcher's data, tables, illustrations, figures, or experimental results without appropriate acknowledgment or necessary permissions.
  • Translation Plagiarism: Translating previously published material from another language without proper attribution.
  • Inappropriate Text Recycling: Reusing substantial portions of one's previously published work without appropriate disclosure, citation, or justification.
  • Duplicate or Redundant Publication: Republishing substantially identical research without appropriate disclosure or legitimate justification.

Not every textual similarity constitutes plagiarism. Properly attributed quotations, common technical expressions, standardized terminology, and some methodological descriptions may legitimately resemble existing sources. The journal evaluates potential plagiarism according to the nature and significance of the overlap.

2. Originality and Authors' Responsibilities

Authors are responsible for ensuring that their submitted manuscripts represent original scholarly work, have not been previously published, and are not under simultaneous consideration by another journal.

Authors must:

  • Appropriately cite all sources that contribute to the research.
  • Clearly identify and attribute directly quoted material.
  • Accurately acknowledge previously published ideas, methods, data, figures, and research findings.
  • Disclose relevant prior publications, preprints, or related manuscripts when necessary to assess overlap.
  • Obtain permission for copyrighted third-party materials where required.
  • Avoid presenting previously published work as a new or independent scientific contribution.
  • Review the manuscript for possible citation errors and inappropriate textual similarities before submission.
  • Cooperate with editorial inquiries concerning originality or attribution.

Authors are encouraged to use similarity-detection software before submission. Such screening can help identify potentially problematic overlap, but does not replace the responsibility to ensure appropriate attribution and originality.

3. Similarity Screening and Editorial Evaluation

Janitra uses plagiarism-detection software, including Turnitin or iThenticate, to support the identification of textual similarities between submitted manuscripts and previously available materials.

Similarity checking supports the initial editorial screening and may also be conducted during subsequent manuscript evaluation when necessary. The Editorial Team assesses the resulting reports to identify possible unattributed copying, excessive text reuse, or substantial overlap with earlier publications.

The similarity percentage must not be interpreted as a direct measurement of plagiarism. Editors should examine the relevant matched passages, their sources, citation practices, and the context of the overlap.

References, correctly attributed quotations, manuscript template elements, and commonly used scientific terminology may influence similarity reports. Conversely, a low overall similarity score does not guarantee that the manuscript is free from plagiarism.

Editorial decisions should therefore rely on the substantive evaluation of potential overlap rather than solely on an automated percentage.

4. Assessment of Suspected Plagiarism

When potentially problematic similarities are identified, the responsible editor should assess the nature, extent, and significance of the overlap before determining the appropriate editorial response.

The assessment should consider:

  • Whether the matched material is appropriately cited or acknowledged.
  • The quantity and significance of overlapping material.
  • Whether the overlap involves background information, research methods, original findings, or conclusions.
  • Whether previously published text, data, or figures have been reused appropriately.
  • Whether the overlap compromises the originality or scientific contribution of the manuscript.
  • The authors' explanations and any relevant supporting documentation.

Authors should ordinarily be given an opportunity to explain the identified overlap and provide relevant clarification before a final adverse determination is made.

Where further examination is necessary, the editor may consult the Editorial Board or suitably qualified experts while maintaining appropriate confidentiality and impartiality.

5. Editorial Actions Before Publication

The editorial response to suspected plagiarism should be proportionate to the seriousness of the identified issue and the available evidence.

Depending on the assessment, possible actions include:

  • No Further Action: Where the overlap is properly attributed or does not constitute a relevant violation.
  • Clarification: Requesting explanations or supporting information from the authors.
  • Manuscript Revision: Requiring improved attribution, appropriate quotations, rewriting of problematic passages, or other necessary corrections.
  • Additional Evaluation: Consulting the Editorial Board or relevant experts when the concern requires further investigation.
  • Manuscript Rejection: Rejecting submissions when serious plagiarism is substantiated or significant concerns remain unresolved.

Requests for revision do not guarantee eventual acceptance. Manuscripts must satisfy all applicable scientific, ethical, and editorial requirements before publication.

6. Plagiarism Identified After Publication

Janitra recognizes that potential plagiarism or inappropriate publication overlap may be identified after an article has been published. Authors, readers, reviewers, and other stakeholders may report substantiated concerns to the Editorial Office.

Post-publication concerns should be assessed objectively using the available evidence, relevant publication records, and explanations provided by the authors. When necessary, the Editorial Board may consult external experts or relevant institutions.

Depending on the findings, appropriate actions may include:

  • Correction: Addressing errors in citation, attribution, or other details where the underlying article remains reliable.
  • Expression of Concern: Alerting readers to significant unresolved concerns requiring further examination.
  • Retraction: Retracting an article when serious plagiarism or other integrity problems undermine its reliability or legitimacy as a publication.
  • No Further Action: Where the allegation is not substantiated.

Formal editorial notices should identify the affected publication, explain the reasons for the action, and remain accessible to readers. Retraction is intended to protect the scholarly record, rather than primarily to impose punishment.

7. Reporting, Confidentiality, and Appeals

Allegations of plagiarism should be reported to the Editorial Office with sufficient information to identify the manuscript or published article and explain the concern.

Reports should include, where available:

  • The manuscript identifier or article title and DOI or URL.
  • A description of the suspected plagiarism or publication overlap.
  • Relevant source publications, matching passages, or supporting evidence.
  • Contact information for further communication.

Reports should be handled confidentially and assessed without prejudice. Individuals with relevant conflicts of interest should not determine the outcome of the case.

Authors may submit a reasoned request for reconsideration of an editorial decision, accompanied by relevant additional evidence. Appeals should receive objective consideration through the appropriate editorial procedures.

The Editorial Board should document relevant findings, decisions, and reasons for the actions taken. Outcomes should be communicated to the concerned parties, subject to applicable confidentiality requirements.

8. Related Policies and Contact Information

This policy should be read alongside Janitra's Plagiarism Checker, Publication Ethics, and applicable research misconduct and correction procedures. For clarification concerning originality requirements or to report potential plagiarism, please contact the Editorial Office.

Editorial Office

Jurnal Janitra Informatika dan Sistem Informasi

Plagiarism Checker: View Plagiarism Checker

Publication Ethics: View Publication Ethics

COPE Guidance: COPE Core Practices

Email: redaksi@janitra.org