Skip to content
Indonesian Scientific Journal

Peer Review Process

Peer Review Process

Jurnal Janitra Informatika dan Sistem Informasi

All manuscripts submitted to Jurnal Janitra Informatika dan Sistem Informasi (Janitra) undergo a structured editorial evaluation and peer-review process to assess their scientific quality, originality, methodological rigor, relevance, and adherence to publication ethics. Submissions must comply with the journal's Focus and Scope, Author Guidelines, and Publication Ethics.

Manuscripts that pass the initial editorial screening are evaluated by at least two reviewers with relevant scientific expertise. Janitra applies a Single-Blind Peer Review model, in which reviewers' identities are concealed from the authors, while reviewers may have access to the authors' identities. Reviewer assessments and recommendations are considered by the Editorial Board in determining the appropriate editorial decision.

Authors may be required to revise their manuscripts in response to reviewer and editorial comments. Additional evaluation or review may be conducted when necessary to determine whether the manuscript meets the journal's publication standards. Completing peer review does not guarantee acceptance, as final publication decisions remain the responsibility of the journal's editors.

Peer Review at a Glance

Review Model: Single-Blind Peer Review
Reviewers: At least two qualified reviewers
Initial Evaluation: Editorial and ethical screening
Revision: Required when requested by the editors
Additional Review: Conducted when necessary
Final Decision: Editorial decision informed by reviewer assessments

Detailed Peer-Review Process

The following ten stages outline Janitra's editorial workflow from manuscript submission to publication and post-publication oversight. Revisions and additional review may be required, depending on the evaluation outcomes and editorial decisions.

1. Manuscript Submission

Authors submit their manuscripts through Janitra's online submission system in accordance with the journal's Author Guidelines and submission requirements. Manuscripts must be original, relevant to the journal's scope, and must not have been previously published or simultaneously submitted to another journal.

Authors are responsible for ensuring that manuscripts follow the required formatting and referencing standards, accurately report research findings, appropriately acknowledge sources, and disclose relevant funding or conflicts of interest. Supporting information or research data may be requested when necessary for editorial evaluation.

2. Editorial Assignment

Following submission, the manuscript is received by the Editorial Office and assigned to an editor responsible for coordinating its evaluation. The assigned editor oversees the screening process, reviewer selection, communication with authors, and assessment of reviewer recommendations.

Editors are expected to maintain confidentiality, exercise professional judgment, and avoid handling manuscripts where conflicts of interest could compromise impartiality.

3. Initial Editorial and Ethical Screening

The editor conducts an initial assessment to determine whether the manuscript is suitable for further review. This screening considers its alignment with the journal's Focus and Scope, originality, research contribution, methodological adequacy, presentation quality, and compliance with submission requirements.

The editorial assessment may also examine potential publication ethics concerns, including plagiarism, redundant publication, inaccurate attribution, questionable research practices, and undisclosed conflicts of interest. Similarity findings are evaluated in their scholarly context rather than treated as automatic evidence of misconduct.

Manuscripts with substantial scope mismatches, serious methodological weaknesses, or unresolved ethical concerns may be rejected without external review. Other submissions may be returned to authors for clarification or preliminary correction.

4. Reviewer Selection and Appointment

Manuscripts that pass initial screening are forwarded to at least two reviewers with expertise relevant to the research topic. Reviewers are selected based on their academic qualifications, subject knowledge, and ability to provide an objective scientific assessment.

Under the journal's Single-Blind Peer Review system, reviewers' identities remain confidential to authors. Reviewers must safeguard manuscript confidentiality, disclose potential conflicts of interest, and conduct their evaluations objectively and professionally.

5. Scientific Peer Review

Reviewers independently evaluate the manuscript's scientific merit, originality, relevance, methodological rigor, validity of results, quality of analysis, interpretation of findings, and contribution to the existing body of knowledge.

Reviewers provide constructive comments identifying strengths, limitations, and improvements necessary to enhance the manuscript's quality. Their recommendations may support acceptance, revision, or rejection, depending on the journal's available editorial decision categories. Reviewers may request clarification, additional analyses, or supporting information where scientifically justified.

Reviewer recommendations support editorial judgment but do not independently determine acceptance.

6. Editorial Assessment of Reviewer Reports

Upon receiving the reviewers' reports, the editor evaluates their assessments and recommendations. The editor considers the significance of the concerns raised, the scientific quality of the manuscript, and whether identified weaknesses can reasonably be addressed through revision.

The manuscript may be recommended for revision, rejection, or further consideration. Where reviewer assessments differ substantially, the editor may seek additional expert evaluation. Editorial recommendations are considered within the journal's established decision-making process.

7. Author Revision and Response

When revision is requested, authors are expected to address the reviewers' and editors' comments carefully and comprehensively. Revised manuscripts should incorporate the necessary scientific, methodological, organizational, and presentation improvements.

Authors should provide a clear point-by-point response indicating how the comments have been addressed. When authors disagree with a suggestion, they should present an academically justified explanation supported by appropriate evidence or reasoning.

The revised manuscript and response materials are submitted through the journal's editorial system for further assessment.

8. Revision Evaluation and Editorial Decision

The editor examines the revised manuscript and authors' responses to determine whether the reviewers' concerns have been adequately addressed. When necessary, the revision may be returned to the original reviewers or evaluated by additional qualified reviewers.

Additional review rounds may be conducted when substantive methodological, analytical, or interpretative issues remain unresolved. The Editorial Board considers the scientific assessments and recommendations before the final editorial decision is communicated to the corresponding author.

Possible outcomes include acceptance, a request for further revision, or rejection. Acceptance depends on the manuscript's scientific merit, successful resolution of relevant concerns, and compliance with the journal's publication standards.

9. Acceptance and Production

Manuscripts approved for publication proceed to the production stage. Editorial preparation may include copy-editing, formatting, bibliographic verification, proofreading, and preparation of the article for publication. Authors may be asked to verify corrections and confirm the accuracy of the final version.

Any applicable Article Processing Charges are administered according to the journal's published Publication Fees policy. Publication charges are billed after acceptance and do not influence the scientific peer-review process or editorial acceptance decision.

10. Publication and Post-Publication Oversight

Following completion of editorial production, the accepted article is published through the journal's online platform and made accessible to readers under its open-access policy. Publication scheduling is managed by the editorial team in accordance with the journal's publication arrangements.

Editorial responsibility continues after publication. Authors, editors, and the publisher are expected to respond appropriately to significant errors, inaccuracies, or potential research misconduct. Where warranted, corrective editorial actions may include issuing corrections or retracting published material in accordance with the journal's publication ethics principles.

Ethical Standards and Editorial Independence

Janitra is committed to maintaining confidentiality, objectivity, academic integrity, and fairness throughout the editorial and peer-review process. Editors and reviewers must evaluate manuscripts based on their intellectual and scientific merits without inappropriate discrimination or conflicts of interest.

The journal's Publication Ethics and Malpractice Statement draws on the principles of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE). Authors must uphold standards of originality, accurate reporting, proper attribution, responsible authorship, and disclosure of relevant conflicts of interest. Reviewers and editors must protect confidential information and avoid using unpublished research for personal advantage.

Complaints and Editorial Correspondence

Authors who wish to raise concerns about manuscript handling, reviewer comments, editorial decisions, or potential publication ethics issues may contact the journal's Editorial Office. Correspondence should identify the manuscript and clearly explain the matter requiring editorial attention. Concerns are considered in accordance with the journal's applicable editorial and ethical responsibilities.

Editorial Office

Jurnal Janitra Informatika dan Sistem Informasi

Email: redaksi@janitra.org

Related Journal Policies

Further information regarding the journal's editorial standards and submission requirements is available through the following official pages: